I knew ya could….

_________

SM: The only innocent person in this case is Trenton Duckett. Neither parent put this child first, NEITHER.

Thanks for posting to me and we can agree to disagree. You have brought up some good points. I think many of us are just frustrated because little Trenton hasn’t been found and as the days slip into weeks it doesn’t look good. People are just airing out their frustrations and trying to figure things out even though we know that’s impossible because none of us have any evidence or the whole story.

Yes, I did misunderstand your post of September 17th and I guess it was the way the last paragraph started off. “Melinda as an evil vile monster that killed her child, then in the next YOU are saying her suicide is staged. When the reality is YOU need to get your head out of the clouds and stop jumping to conclusions and creating conspiracies; the truth is we only know what the authorities want us to know. Get a grip people! Because you did not use “all of you” and just “you” I assumed you meant me. You have since explained you meant all posters.

My brother-in-laws death only tells me one thing … people shouldn’t judge until the juries in. His death is not clouding my judgement at all. Yes, I have put out the theory of someone possibly making it look like Melinda committed suicide, but by no means am I not open to others opinions. It was simply “food for thought.”

I do agree it looks “fishy”. There was a case in Canada 3 years ago that indeed a child was taken from a screened window and it was not totally taken out of the window frame. As you put it “why wouldn’t the kidnapper just take the screen out” is a valid question, but who knows what a person like that would do. If they were sane they wouldn’t have taken the child in the first place or Melinda wouldn’t have accidently or on purpose harmed her own child.

I think my theory of more people involved in the disappearance of Trenton is not far off and only my opinon and like anyone else I have a right to that opinon and just put it on my post as an open opinion to mull over. This has nothing to do with my brother-in-law’s misguided suicide, but of murder. I think all of us here would like nothing better than Trenton found and hopefully alive.

I had Nancy Grace on tonight just to see if anything new came up and at first glance I thought they had found Trenton, but it was a little girl they had found alive.

If what you say is true and I quote, “I am just stating that the public does NOT know all of the facts and we should all stop jumping to conclusions.” This is what these boards are for, to give theories and express oneself when a person feels frustrated and hoping and praying for little Trenton to be found alive. Theories are naturally going to come of it because that’s about all any of us can do at this point in time.

Again, thanks for responding and I appreciate it.

Thank you for your kinds words re my brother-in-law. I know for a fact that the coroner does not release all information for many reasons and will often mislead the media. The less people know about the case the more chances they have of finding Trenton (hopefully alive) and if not who did kill him. It is a possibility (we have cops in our family who have said this) that the truth in the coroners report may never be told and “suicide” mentioned by the coroner and police department was to mislead anyone who had anything to do with it into thinking this would be and open and shut case and that Melinda murdered her own son. If it was Melinda then God will handle things and it’s out of our hands, but all of us must be sure they get the right person.

I am no more creating a conspiracy theory than you are. You have practically condemned this young woman and know nothing about her. I see her as a stranger and the last time I looked one was innocent until proven guilty. How easy it is to jump on her dead body since she isn’t around to defend herself. This is going to be a tough once since Melinda has passed on. I have no doubt her lawyer told her to keep her mouth shut (as most lawyers do).

I think you should read my posts more closely because I NEVER accused this girl once of being an evil and vile monster. “Get our heads of out of the clouds … you certainly have given your theories and that’s what this board is about. Most people are trying their best in their own way to make sense of all this.

I have a question for some of you that think she did it .. is this the witches of Salem all over again. Doesn’t anyone learn from past mistakes?

While many can guess and even back-stab this young woman the real perpetrator could be getting away.

One thing I haven’t done, is EVER condemned this woman because I feel God only has that right and none of us!

The hope here is that Trenton will be found alive and well. The police think as the days go by his chances of being found alive are slim, but it has happened often where someone has the child. Look at the girl on the news that was held captive for years and finally escaped. A miracle can always happen and here’s hoping one is going to happen for Trenton.